> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://souljourneywisdom.life/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Spiritual Guidance: What It Is and How to Choose a Guide You Can Trust
- URL: https://souljourneywisdom.life/spiritual-guidance-how-to-choose-a-guide/
- Published: 2026-11-03T21:40:20.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-03T22:03:34.000Z
- Description: Spiritual guidance should leave you more able to think for yourself, not less. Here is what it is, how it differs from therapy, and the questions that help you choose well.
- Author: Mark Demaine
- Tags: guides, Spiritual Healing, Shamanic Practice, Ancestral Trauma

Dr Mark Demaine is a spiritual healing practitioner and ancestral trauma specialist.

Spiritual guidance is steady, mature, one-to-one support in making sense of your inner life, your beliefs and your next steps. A good guide helps you think for yourself. They are open to the training that you’ve already had, your experiences (good and bad), as well as your limits. They will work alongside any medical or therapeutic care, and never pressure you to buy, stay or obey. The way to find a guide who matches what you need is to ask lots of questions. A good guide will listen, understand what you need, and then make clear offerings that demand nothing from you. They do this through integrity and by explaining plainly what they can and cannot offer, never through charisma, urgency, danger or fear.

If you are reading this, you may want to deepen your relationship with spirit, the divine, Gaia, the god or goddess of your understanding (by whatever name you use), with the help of a real person and not another book or AI agent that tells you what you want to hear. You know something has shifted, or stalled, or has nagged at you for years, and the people around you don’t share your words for it - or perhaps, they don’t know what to say. So looking for a guide then is natural. You are also more open than usual, which is why it pays to choose with care.

I offer one-to-one guidance on spiritual questions and the patterns that sit beneath them. My work includes clearing inherited and emotional baggage. This guide is my working view of what spiritual guidance is, what to look for, what to be wary of, and how to tell the difference. The questions in it are ones I am glad to be asked. It is for the evening when you have a dozen browser tabs open and want something plain to read.

## What is spiritual guidance?

Spiritual guidance is a relationship in which one person accompanies another through questions of meaning, inner experience and direction. It may involve conversation, practices, reflection or ceremony with a longer term view of empowering you to become more whole, stronger and clearer of mind. The aim is that you leave more able to tap into your own clear sense of things, and be less reliant on the guide. Reliance on a good guide should be temporary, because the end goal is always to help you recognise the gifts within yourself so that you become self-reliant.

People come to me for many reasons: Some have had an experience they cannot explain and want company while they find their footing. Some have left a faith behind and want to find something that fits. Some feel a weight they cannot account for, or a sadness or fear that seems older than their own life, sometimes called generational or ancestral trauma, and want some help in understanding it. Others are at a crossroads: a loss, a move, a change of work, a sense that the old way of living no longer fits, but they feel lost at sea.

Here is how it can sound. These are composite situations, not individual clients:

*"I grew up in a church and left at nineteen. I don't miss the dogma, but I do miss having that connection to the divine and having someone who can answer the big questions."*

*"After my father died I started noticing things I couldn't explain, and I haven't told anyone. I'm not frightened exactly. I just want someone to talk to who won't flinch."*

*"I've done years of self-help. I understand myself very well. Something is still stuck, and I can't think my way to it."*

These are strong, capable people who want a trustworthy person to think alongside. That is what spiritual guidance, at its best, offers.

Here is one real account, shared with her permission and with nothing that could identify her. She came to me confused about a difficult turn in her working life, wondering whether it was down to something she had done. In her session we worked with a pattern around the misuse of power in her family line. A few days later she told me that things at home felt different and warmer, and some weeks after that she described a change at work. These are her words and her experience of the weeks that followed. I cannot say what part the session played, and every person's experience is their own.

## How do I get spiritual guidance, and do I need a teacher or coach?

You don’t *need* one. Many people find their way alone, with books, practice, nature and good friends. A guide helps when you feel stuck, when an experience is bigger than you can hold alone, or when you want someone outside your family and friends who will listen without an agenda. If you decide you want one, the sections below show how to find and choose well.

The words overlap, so here is how I use them:

**Teacher** usually means someone who passes on a tradition or a body of teaching: meditation, a lineage, a set of practices. You learn a path – their path.

**Coach** usually means someone who helps you set and work towards goals. The emphasis is on action and accountability.

**Guide or mentor** usually means someone who walks alongside you with more experience, helping you read your own situation. The emphasis is on discernment. They will help you with your own interpretation of what you experienced.

Real people mix these. The label matters less than whether the person is honest about what they do, how they do it, and what they cannot do. Anyone can give themselves a title.

## Should I see a therapist or a spiritual guide, and how are they different?

Therapy works within a clinical framework and is usually aimed at diagnosing, understanding and easing psychological difficulty. Spiritual guidance works with meaning, inner experience, practice and your relationship to something larger than yourself. They overlap, and many people use both a therapist and a spiritual guide or healer. Neither should ask you to drop the other.

I think of it as two kinds of company. A therapist, counsellor or psychiatrist brings training in how minds and relationships work, and a duty of care set by a professional framework. A spiritual guide brings experience of the inner and spiritual terrain, and can often meet questions that a clinical setting leaves untouched: "What does this mean?", "Why does this feel older than me?", "What am I here to do?"

Two practical points follow.

First, a good guide is comfortable with you having other support. The sessions I offer fit alongside any care you have from a doctor or therapist. I would be concerned about any guide who asked you to stop either, as they have no right to do so.

Second, "therapist or spiritual guide?" is often a false either/or. For some people it is both, at different times. For others it is whoever they trust first. To read more on how the two sit together, I have written about [how shamanic practice works alongside modern approaches to wellbeing.](https://souljourneywisdom.life/how-shamanic-practice-works-alongside-modern-therapy/)

## When is a good time to look for a guide?

A good time is when you are curious and steady enough to question a stranger and weigh the answers. A harder time is the middle of a storm, when exhaustion, fear or loneliness can make the first confident voice sound like the right one.

![A woman sitting quietly by a bright window with a cup of tea, in a warm room full of books](https://storage.ghost.io/c/35/2c/352ca57e-4ccb-4068-bb3a-e38f275050bb/content/images/2026/11/2-inline-reflective-window.png)

If you are unsettled right now, perhaps after an intense experience, start with steadiness and choose a guide a little later. My article on [spiritual experiences that need grounding](https://souljourneywisdom.life/spiritual-experiences-that-need-grounding/) covers what to do in the first hour and the first week. You do not have to decide anything tonight.

There is a research reason for care too. Difficult experiences in contemplative practice are not rare. In a study of 96 people who took part in an eight-week mindfulness programme, 83 per cent reported at least one meditation-related side effect, which included neutral and positive effects as well as difficult ones; 58 per cent reported at least one difficult effect. 6 to 14 per cent reported lasting difficulties, depending on whether lasting meant more than a month or more than a day ([Britton et al., *Clinical Psychological Science*, 2021](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8845498?ref=souljourneywisdom.life)). Interviews with Western Buddhist meditators catalogued a wide range of challenging experiences, including altered perception, strong emotion and changes in how the body feels ([Lindahl et al., *PLOS ONE*, 2017](https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5443484/?ref=souljourneywisdom.life)). Those studies are about meditation, not every spiritual path. They do show that inner work can be powerful, and that a person guiding it needs to know what to do when it is.

## What does a good spiritual guide actually do?

A good guide listens more than they talk, keeps the pace yours, explains what they are doing and why, and is clear about what they can and cannot offer. They may offer perspectives and viewpoints that you’ve not considered, but they are there to help you with your perspective. They help you build your own discernment. You should always leave a session with more of your own authority - not less.

I look for five things.

1. **They listen first.** Before offering a reading, a theory or a practice, they ask what is going on for you and take the answer seriously.
2. **They slow things down.** If you are overwhelmed, they steady and ground you before going deeper.
3. **They are transparent.** You know what happens in a session, what it involves and how to stop.
4. **They name their limits.** They do not diagnose, do not promise outcomes, and say so.
5. **They point you back to yourself.** The aim is your own insight and your own life, not their importance in it.

That last one is the heart of it. A good sign is feeling more capable, more yourself and more connected to the people in your life. Feeling more dependent, more secretive or more cut off is worth noticing.

## How do I choose a trustworthy spiritual guide, coach or mentor?

Ask questions before you commit, and notice how they are received. A trustworthy guide welcomes questions about training, method, boundaries and payment, and answers them plainly. Asking is not rude. How someone answers a fair question tells you a good deal about how they will treat you.

![A person with a rucksack pausing on a forest path, looking ahead in soft light](https://storage.ghost.io/c/35/2c/352ca57e-4ccb-4068-bb3a-e38f275050bb/content/images/2026/11/3-inline-forest-path-discernment.png)

Here are ten questions I am glad to be asked. Put them to anyone, including me.

**1\. What is your training and background, and where did it come from?** Look for a clear, specific answer: who taught them, over how long, in what tradition. Vagueness is a flag, and so is a long list of impressive-sounding titles with no detail.

**2\. What exactly will happen in a session?** You should be able to picture it. Talking only? Practices? Hands-on work? Ceremony? Nothing should be a surprise.

**3\. What do you not do, and what would make you refer me elsewhere?** A good guide has an easy answer. If the answer is "nothing, I can help with anything", step back.

**4\. How do you work alongside my doctor or therapist?** The right reply is welcoming. Anyone who discourages you from continuing existing care is a concern.

**5\. How does payment work, and can I stop at any time?** You should hear the full picture up front, with no hidden extras and no pressure to book a bundle.

**6\. What do you do when someone is overwhelmed in a session?** A prepared person has a plain answer: slow down, ground, stop if needed.

**7\. Can I take time to decide?** There should be no countdown clocks, no "this offer ends tonight", no suggestion that waiting will harm you.

**8\. How do you handle confidentiality?** They should be clear about what stays private, and about any rare exceptions.

**9\. Who supports you in this work?** The best guides have their own mentor, supervision or community. Nobody holds this kind of work alone.

**10\. What would you like me to bring to the first conversation, and what would you like me to leave out?** An open, simple answer is a good sign.

Notice what they say and how it feels in your body as they say it. Settled and respected is a good sign. Hurried, flattered or slightly afraid is worth pausing on. To learn more about reading those body signals, my [Somatic Healing Guide](https://souljourneywisdom.life/somatic-healing-guide/) is a gentle place to begin.

## What are the red flags of a spiritual scam, and how do I avoid them?

The clearest red flags are pressure, secrecy and dependence. Be cautious of anyone who creates urgency, claims special powers only they hold (or only a select few can ever know about), promises particular results, discourages other support, or makes leaving feel dangerous or disloyal.

Here is a plain checklist.

**Pressure.** Limited-time offers, upselling to bigger and bigger programmes, guilt if you hesitate.

**Guarantees.** Promises to cure, fix, heal or transform. No honest guide can promise what will happen for you.

**Fear.** Telling you that you are cursed, in danger, carrying something dark, or that only they can remove it.

**Isolation.** Suggesting your family, friends, doctor or therapist are the problem, or that you should keep sessions secret.

**Special status.** Claiming unique access, a chosen role or knowledge nobody else has, with an expectation of deference.

**No questions allowed.** Treating doubt as resistance, ego or a lack of faith.

**Blurred boundaries.** Asking for favours, gifts, money outside the agreed fee, or personal involvement unrelated to the work.

**Diagnosis.** Telling you what is medically or psychologically wrong with you.

One composite situation, to make this concrete:

*"She told me my grandmother's curse was blocking everything, and that I'd need three more sessions to lift it – as long as I paid now - in advance! When I said I wanted to think about it, she said the longer I waited the worse it would get."*

Fear, a quick fix, a prepaid bundle and a deadline, all in one conversation. If you hear a pattern like that, it is fine to say "thank you, I'll think about it" and leave. A good guide will not mind at all.

## Do qualifications matter, and what should I make of them?

Qualifications show that someone has studied seriously, but they are only part of the picture. Spiritual guidance is not regulated by law in the UK, and there is no single register that covers it. Many capable practitioners appear in no directory, which leaves much of the checking to you and makes direct questions all the more useful.

What I would weigh, roughly in this order:

**Lived experience of the work.** How long have they done it, and with whom? Can they describe their approach in plain words?

**Lineage or training.** Who taught them, and can that teacher or tradition be checked?

**Formal study.** Degrees and certificates tell you about commitment and depth of their subject knowledge. Most of the time they are not clinical qualifications unless the course says so, and they should not be presented as such.

**Their own practice and support.** Do they have their own mentor, supervision or community?

**Clear boundaries.** Do they describe what they do honestly, without claiming medical authority?

On my own background, plainly: I hold a Ph.D in Philosophy specialising in Ancestral Trauma and an M.MSc in Metaphysical Science. These are theocentric degrees that I studied in the field of metaphysical science. I chose them to deepen my understanding from my work in shamanic practice, and I am glad to name the institutions or my mentors to anyone who asks. My training includes initiation in shamanic practice, and my practice draws on multi-modal energy healing across several lineages. Before this I spent over two decades in leadership roles across FTSE 100 organisations and military service, as well as transformational roles with the United Nations. I am also the author of [*Somatic Healing for the Soul*](https://souljourneywisdom.life/somatic-healing-guide/). I tell you this so you can check it. I would ask any guide to be equally open with you.

## How do I find a legitimate shaman or practitioner near me?

Start with the same questions as for any guide, then add a few specific to shamanic and energy work. Ask who initiated or trained them, what tradition the practice comes from, and how they treat the people and cultures it came from. A legitimate practitioner answers without mystique and does not need you to be impressed. For my own part, I am glad to answer that question in conversation.

Three further pointers.

**Be careful with the word "shaman".** In its original sense it belongs to particular cultures, and many use it loosely. Ask where the person's training sits and who recognised it. Honest answers are usually specific, humble and checkable.

**Distance is not a disadvantage.** Many good practitioners work by video. "Near me" matters far less than "right for me".

**Ask about safety.** Shamanic and energy work can bring strong feelings to the surface. A prepared practitioner has a plain answer for what happens if you feel overwhelmed, and welcomes you keeping your doctor or therapist in the picture.

## What does a first conversation look like?

A first conversation should feel like a meeting between two adults. You say what has brought you. The guide listens, explains how they work, answers your questions and tells you honestly whether they can help. You are free to leave without booking anything.

![Two women talking calmly in a warm, plant-filled room, seated in armchairs](https://storage.ghost.io/c/35/2c/352ca57e-4ccb-4068-bb3a-e38f275050bb/content/images/2026/11/4-inline-first-conversation.png)

If you go on to a first session with me, this is how I run it. I begin by asking what you would most like help with. I then explain the process for that session and ask your permission to feel into your energetic space. Once you have said yes, I create a safe energetic boundary around us both, so that the work happens inside it. Through a series of questions, I explore whether the issue sits in your own space or whether you may have inherited it. If it seems to be inherited, I look for where it comes from and work at that level. When that is complete, I tell you what I worked with, and then clear your own energetic field again to close. Body-based energy work and breathing usually run alongside this, and you can say no or stop at any point.

I offer a [free Discovery Call](https://souljourneywisdom.life/book-session/) for this purpose. You can tell me what you are experiencing, ask me anything from the list above, and decide whether my sessions might fit alongside the care you already have. There is no commitment and no pressure to go further. Sometimes the honest outcome is that someone else would suit you better, and I will say so.

## How do I work as a guide?

My working view, drawn from practice, is that most of what people carry is not theirs. Fear, grief and heaviness often seem to arrive from further back than a person's own life. That view comes from years of inquiry and my doctoral work, and it is why my focus is ancestral trauma, which many people search for as generational trauma. This is my view from practice and inquiry, not an established scientific finding.

So I start with the person in front of me. I listen to what is going on in their internal and external lives that they are living. Where it feels as though it has come from somewhere older, I explore that gently and at their pace. I pay attention to the body as well as the story, because I find the body often tells us what words do not. Some of the work is conversation, and some draws on the many practices I trained in.

Two things matter to me. I ask people what their experience means to them, because it is theirs. And I describe what I do and leave the results open, because nobody can know them. What I offer is steady, attentive company and a way of working that keeps you in charge of your own life.

If the lineage angle is new to you, my [Ancestral Trauma Healing Guide](https://souljourneywisdom.life/ancestral-trauma-healing-guide/) explains how generational and ancestral trauma are passed down, and the [Somatic Healing Guide](https://souljourneywisdom.life/somatic-healing-guide/) covers the body-based side of the work.

## How will I know if it is helping?

Look at your ordinary life. In a good relationship with a guide you may notice more clarity, more steadiness and a clearer sense of your own judgement. Nobody can predict what you will notice or when. This kind of work is not linear, and each person moves at their own pace.

A few questions you can ask yourself after a session or two:

- Do I feel more like myself, or less?
- Do I understand what we did and why?
- Was I treated with respect when I asked questions or said no?
- Am I more connected to the people in my life, or more cut off?
- Do I feel free to stop?

If the answers worry you, trust that. Changing guide, or stopping, is a legitimate choice.

## Would it help to talk it through?

If you would like to talk with someone who will not hurry you, [book a free Discovery Call](https://souljourneywisdom.life/book-session/). Bring your questions, including the difficult ones ;-).

## Frequently asked questions

### What is spiritual guidance in simple terms?

It is one-to-one support in making sense of your inner life, beliefs and direction. A guide listens, offers perspective and sometimes practices, and helps you trust your own judgement. It works alongside, and does not replace, any medical or therapeutic care you have.

### Do I need a spiritual teacher or coach?

No. Many people manage without one. A guide helps when you feel stuck, when an experience is bigger than you can hold alone, or when you want an outside listener with no agenda. The label matters less than their honesty and boundaries.

### How can I tell if a spiritual guide is genuine or a scam?

Ask about training, method, boundaries and payment, and notice how they respond. A genuine guide answers plainly, welcomes your other support and lets you take time. Pressure, guarantees, fear and secrecy are the signs to step back from.

### Is spiritual guidance the same as therapy?

No. Therapy works within a clinical framework. Spiritual guidance works with meaning, inner experience and practice. They overlap, and many people use both. A good guide is comfortable with you having other support and never asks you to stop it.

### What should I ask at a first meeting?

Ask about their training, what happens in a session, what they do not do, how they work with your other care, how payment works, and whether you can take time to decide. A good guide will be glad you asked.

### How do I find a trustworthy spiritual coach or mentor and avoid scams?

I would ask about training, method, boundaries and payment before committing, and notice how the answers land. Be cautious of urgency, guarantees, fear, secrecy and anyone who discourages your other support. A trustworthy coach or mentor welcomes questions and lets you take time to decide.

### How do I find a legitimate shaman or practitioner near me?

I would ask who trained or initiated them, which tradition the practice comes from, and what they do if you feel overwhelmed. Honest answers are specific and checkable. Many good practitioners work by video, so "near me" matters less than whether the person is right for you.

### Should I see a therapist or a spiritual healer?

In my experience it is often both, at different times, and neither should ask you to drop the other. Therapy works within a clinical framework to ease psychological difficulty. Spiritual guidance works with meaning, inner experience and practice. A good guide is comfortable with you having other support.

---

*Dr Mark Demaine is a spiritual healing practitioner and ancestral trauma specialist.* He is the founder of [Soul Journey Wisdom](https://souljourneywisdom.life/about/) and author of [*Somatic Healing for the Soul*](https://souljourneywisdom.life/somatic-healing-guide/).

### Related reading

- [Ancestral Trauma Healing: A Complete Guide](https://souljourneywisdom.life/ancestral-trauma-healing-guide/)
- [The Somatic Healing Guide](https://souljourneywisdom.life/somatic-healing-guide/)
- [How Shamanic Practice Works Alongside Modern Approaches to Wellbeing](https://souljourneywisdom.life/how-shamanic-practice-works-alongside-modern-therapy/)
- [Floating, Flooded or Frightened After a Spiritual Experience? How to Ground First](https://souljourneywisdom.life/spiritual-experiences-that-need-grounding/)

[Disclaimer](https://souljourneywisdom.life/terms-and-conditions/#7-disclaimers)